The community is mourning the loss of 16-year-old Matthew “Mateo” Alfaro after his family identified his body following days of searching for the missing teenager in the Milliken and Greeley areas of Colorado.
Matthew was reported missing after he was last seen in the Milliken area over the weekend. According to a family fundraiser organized by Cynthia Alfaro, he was reportedly seen around 1 a.m. on November 7 walking east along Highway 60 toward Greeley.
As concern grew, his family appealed to residents and businesses along the route and near Highway 257 to review surveillance footage that might help investigators determine his whereabouts. The initial fundraiser sought donations for search-related expenses, including flyers, tracking services and other efforts to locate him.
Body Found Near Highway 257
On November 9, emergency personnel responded to an area near mile marker 1 on Colorado Highway 257, north of Highway 60, following a report that prompted a death investigation.
An initial local report said the identity of the deceased person had not yet been officially confirmed. Investigators had also not established the circumstances or cause of death.
By November 10, 9NEWS reported that Matthew’s family had identified the body as their missing son. The report also stated that Milliken police were investigating.
The family’s GoFundMe campaign, renamed “In Loving Memory of Matthew ‘Mateo’ Alfaro,” confirms that he was found deceased. Donations are now being directed toward funeral and memorial arrangements and support for his loved ones.
Friends Remember Matthew “Mateo” Alfaro
Following the news, friends and community members shared heartfelt tributes, remembering Matthew as a kind, friendly and caring young person who was willing to help others.
Luis Ornelas remembered him as a good friend who was often in a positive mood. Gabriela Varela also described Matthew as someone who cared about people and offered help whenever it was needed.
Other messages expressed sadness over his passing and sympathy for the family. Their words reflect the affection Matthew inspired among those who knew him.
Cause and Circumstances of Death Remain Unknown
Although Matthew’s family has identified him as the teenager found near Highway 257, the cause and manner of his death have not been established in the reports available.
The initial account described the discovery as part of a death investigation, but no confirmed explanation of what happened has been released in the information provided. Until investigators share verified findings, no conclusion should be drawn about whether the death involved an accident, illness or criminal activity.
Condolences to the Alfaro Family
Matthew was just 16 years old. His death is a heartbreaking loss for his parents, siblings, relatives, friends and the wider community.
As loved ones grieve, the memories and tributes shared by those who knew him offer a reminder of the impact he had on their lives. Heartfelt condolences go to the entire Alfaro family and everyone affected by this loss.
May Matthew “Mateo” Alfaro rest in peace, and may his loved ones find strength and comfort in the days ahead.
